Pension Security and Transparency Act of 2005

the House held a roll-call vote on 109-hr2830 (Pension Security and Transparency Act of 2005). Tallies — Yea: 200, Nay: 227, Present: 0, Not Voting: 0, Total recorded: 433.

109-hr2830 109th Congress House Died in Committee
XML

Bill Activity

House
Introduced in House
Referred to the Committee on Education and the Workforce, and in addition to the Committee on Ways and Means, for a period to be subsequently determined by the Speaker, in each case for consideration of such provisions as fall within the jurisdiction of the committee concerned.
Committee Hearings Held.
Forwarded by Subcommittee to Full Committee (Amended) by Voice Vote.
Ordered to be Reported (Amended) by the Yeas and Nays: 27 - 0.
House Committee on Ways and Means Granted an extension for further consideration ending not later than Sept. 30, 2005.
House Committee on Ways and Means Granted an extension for further consideration ending not later than Nov. 4, 2005.
House Committee on Ways and Means Granted an extension for further consideration ending not later than Nov. 18, 2005.
Ordered to be Reported (Amended) by the Yeas and Nays: 23 - 17.
House Committee on Ways and Means Granted an extension for further consideration ending not later than Dec. 6, 2005.
Reported (Amended) by the Committee on Ways and Means. H. Rept. 109-232, Part II.
Rules Committee Resolution H. Res. 602 Reported to House. Rule provides for consideration of H.R. 2830 with 1 hour and 30 minutes of general debate. Previous question shall be considered as ordered without intervening motions except motion to recommit with or without instructions. In lieu of the amendments recommended by the Committees on Education and the Workforce and Ways and Means now printed in the bill, the amendment in the nature of a substitute printed in part A of the report of the Committee on Rules accompanying this resolution shall be considered as adopted. Measure will be considered read. Bill is closed to amendments. During consideration of H.R. 2830 pursuant to this resolution, notwithstanding the operation of the previous question, the Chair may postpone further consideration of the bill to a time designated by the Speaker.
Rule provides for consideration of H.R. 2830 with 1 hour and 30 minutes of general debate. Previous question shall be considered as ordered without intervening motions except motion to recommit with or without instructions. In lieu of the amendments recommended by the Committees on Education and the Workforce and Ways and Means now printed in the bill, the amendment in the nature of a substitute printed in part A of the report of the Committee on Rules accompanying this resolution shall be considered as adopted. Measure will be considered read. Bill is closed to amendments. During consideration of H.R. 2830 pursuant to this resolution, notwithstanding the operation of the previous question, the Chair may postpone further consideration of the bill to a time designated by the Speaker.
Senate insists on its amendment, asks for a conference, appoints conferees Grassley; Hatch; Lott; Snowe; Santorum; Enzi; Gregg; DeWine; Isakson; Baucus; Rockefeller; Conrad; Bingaman; Kennedy; Harkin; Mikulski.
The Speaker appointed a conferee for consideration of the House bill and the Senate amendment thereto, and modifications committed to conference: Boehner.
The Speaker appointed conferees - from the Committee on Ways and Means for consideration of the House bill and the Senate amendment thereto, and modifications committed to conference: Thomas, Camp (MI), and Rangel.
Passed/agreed to in House: On passage Passed by recorded vote: 294 - 132 (Roll no. 635).(text: CR H11678-11753)
DEBATE - The House proceeded with one hour of debate on the George Miller of California motion to instruct conferees. Instructions seek to direct the managers on the part of the House to (1) agree to the provisions contained in sections 403 and 413 of the Senate amendment; (2) insist on the provisions contained in section 907 of the bill as passed by the House; (3) insist on the provisions contained in section 902 of the bill as passed by the House; and (4) insist on a conference report that imposes the smallest additional funding requirements (permitted within the scope of conference) on companies that sponsor pension plans if there is no reasonable likelihood the termination of the plan would impose additional liabilities to the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation or there is no reasonable likelihood the plan sponsor would terminate the plan in bankruptcy.
DEBATE - The House proceeded with one hour of debate on the George Miller (CA) motion to instruct conferees. Instructions contained within the motion seek to instruct the managers on the part of the House to agree to the provisions contained in the Senate amendment regarding the prohibition of wearaway in connection with conversions to cash balance plans and the establishment of procedures affecting participants' benefits in connection with the conversion to such plans and not agree to the provisions contained in title VII of the bill as passed by the House.
DEBATE - The House proceeded with one hour of debate on the George Miller (CA) motion to instruct conferees. Instructions seek to direct the managers on the part of the House to recede to the provisions contained in the Senate amendment regarding restrictions on funding of nonqualified deferred compensation plans, except that (1) the managers insist that the restrictions regarding executive compensation, including under nonqualified plans, be the same as restrictions regarding benefits for workers and retirees under qualified pension plans, (2) managers insist that the definition of "covered employee" include the CEO of the plan sponsor, any other employee of the plan sponsor who is a "covered employee", and any other individual who is an officer or employee within the meaning of section 16(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and (3) managers shall insist on the date in the House passed bill.
DEBATE - The House proceeded with one hour of debate on the George Miller (CA) motion to instruct conferees. Instructions seek to direct the managers on the part of the House to agree to the provisions contained in subsections (a) through (d) of section 601 of the Senate amendment; not to agree with the provisions contained in title VII of the bill as passed the House; and agree to the provisions contained in section 413 of the Senate amendment, but only with respect to plan terminations occurring on or after September 11, 2001.
Senate
On motion to recommit with instructions Failed by the Yeas and Nays: 200 - 227 (Roll no. 634). (consideration: CR H11771-11797)
Passed Senate with an amendment by Unanimous Consent.
Failed 200–227
200 Yea (46.8%) 227 Nay (53.2%)
Democrats
199 Yea 1 Nay
Republicans
0 Yea 226 Nay
Independents
1 Yea 0 Nay
Yea: 200 Nay: 227 Present: 0 Not Voting: 0 Total: 433
Shown: 433
Member Party State Vote
Abercrombie D Yea
Ackerman D Yea
Allen D Yea
Andrews D Yea
Baca D Yea
Baird D Yea
Baldwin D Yea
Barrow D Yea
Bean D Yea
Becerra D Yea
Berkley D Yea
Berman D Yea
Berry D Yea
Bishop (GA) D Yea
Bishop (NY) D Yea
Blumenauer D Yea
Boren D Yea
Boswell D Yea
Boucher D Yea
Boyd D Yea
Brady (PA) D Yea
Brown (OH) D Yea
Brown, Corrine D Yea
Butterfield D Yea
Capps D Yea
Capuano D Yea
Cardin D Yea
Cardoza D Yea
Carnahan D Yea
Carson D Yea
Case D Yea
Chandler D Yea
Clay D Yea
Cleaver D Yea
Clyburn D Yea
Conyers D Yea
Cooper D Yea
Costa D Yea
Costello D Yea
Cramer D Yea
Crowley D Yea
Cuellar D Yea
Cummings D Yea
Davis (AL) D Yea
Davis (CA) D Yea
Davis (IL) D Yea
Davis (TN) D Yea
DeFazio D Yea
DeGette D Yea
DeLauro D Yea
Delahunt D Yea
Dicks D Yea
Dingell D Yea
Doggett D Yea
Doyle D Yea
Edwards D Yea
Emanuel D Yea
Engel D Yea
Eshoo D Yea
Etheridge D Yea
Evans D Yea
Farr D Yea
Fattah D Yea
Filner D Yea
Ford D Yea
Frank (MA) D Yea
Gonzalez D Yea
Gordon D Yea
Green, Al D Yea
Green, Gene D Yea
Grijalva D Yea
Gutierrez D Yea
Harman D Yea
Hastings (FL) D Yea
Herseth D Yea
Higgins D Yea
Hinchey D Yea
Hinojosa D Yea
Holden D Yea
Holt D Yea
Honda D Yea
Hooley D Yea
Hoyer D Yea
Inslee D Yea
Israel D Yea
Jackson (IL) D Yea
Jackson-Lee (TX) D Yea
Jefferson D Yea
Johnson, E. B. D Yea
Jones (OH) D Yea
Kanjorski D Yea
Kaptur D Yea
Kennedy (RI) D Yea
Kildee D Yea
Kilpatrick (MI) D Yea
Kind D Yea
Kucinich D Yea
Langevin D Yea
Lantos D Yea
Larsen (WA) D Yea
Larson (CT) D Yea
Lee D Yea
Levin D Yea
Lewis (GA) D Yea
Lipinski D Yea
Lofgren, Zoe D Yea
Lowey D Yea
Lynch D Yea
Maloney D Yea
Markey D Yea
Marshall D Yea
Matsui D Yea
McCarthy D Yea
McCollum (MN) D Yea
McDermott D Yea
McGovern D Yea
McIntyre D Yea
McKinney D Yea
McNulty D Yea
Meehan D Yea
Meek (FL) D Yea
Meeks (NY) D Yea
Melancon D Yea
Menendez D Yea
Michaud D Yea
Millender-McDonald D Yea
Miller (NC) D Yea
Miller, George D Yea
Mollohan D Yea
Moore (KS) D Yea
Moore (WI) D Yea
Moran (VA) D Yea
Murtha D Yea
Nadler D Yea
Napolitano D Yea
Neal (MA) D Yea
Oberstar D Yea
Obey D Yea
Olver D Yea
Ortiz D Yea
Owens D Yea
Pallone D Yea
Pascrell D Yea
Pastor D Yea
Payne D Yea
Pelosi D Yea
Peterson (MN) D Yea
Pomeroy D Yea
Price (NC) D Yea
Rahall D Yea
Rangel D Yea
Reyes D Yea
Ross D Yea
Rothman D Yea
Roybal-Allard D Yea
Ruppersberger D Yea
Rush D Yea
Ryan (OH) D Yea
Sabo D Yea
Salazar D Yea
Sanchez, Linda T. D Yea
Sanchez, Loretta D Yea
Schakowsky D Yea
Schiff D Yea
Schwartz (PA) D Yea
Scott (GA) D Yea
Scott (VA) D Yea
Serrano D Yea
Sherman D Yea
Skelton D Yea
Slaughter D Yea
Smith (WA) D Yea
Snyder D Yea
Solis D Yea
Spratt D Yea
Stark D Yea
Strickland D Yea
Stupak D Yea
Tanner D Yea
Tauscher D Yea
Taylor (MS) D Yea
Thompson (CA) D Yea
Thompson (MS) D Yea
Tierney D Yea
Towns D Yea
Udall (CO) D Yea
Udall (NM) D Yea
Van Hollen D Yea
Velazquez D Yea
Visclosky D Yea
Wasserman Schultz D Yea
Watson D Yea
Watt D Yea
Waxman D Yea
Weiner D Yea
Wexler D Yea
Woolsey D Yea
Wu D Yea
Wynn D Yea
Sanders I Yea
Matheson D Nay
Aderholt R Nay
Akin R Nay
Alexander R Nay
Bachus R Nay
Baker R Nay
Barrett (SC) R Nay
Bartlett (MD) R Nay
Barton (TX) R Nay
Bass R Nay
Beauprez R Nay
Biggert R Nay
Bilirakis R Nay
Bishop (UT) R Nay
Blackburn R Nay
Blunt R Nay
Boehlert R Nay
Boehner R Nay
Bonilla R Nay
Bonner R Nay
Bono R Nay
Boozman R Nay
Boustany R Nay
Bradley (NH) R Nay
Brady (TX) R Nay
Brown (SC) R Nay
Brown-Waite, Ginny R Nay
Burgess R Nay
Burton (IN) R Nay
Buyer R Nay
Calvert R Nay
Camp (MI) R Nay
Campbell (CA) R Nay
Cannon R Nay
Cantor R Nay
Capito R Nay
Carter R Nay
Castle R Nay
Chabot R Nay
Chocola R Nay
Coble R Nay
Cole (OK) R Nay
Conaway R Nay
Crenshaw R Nay
Cubin R Nay
Culberson R Nay
Davis (KY) R Nay
Davis, Jo Ann R Nay
Davis, Tom R Nay
DeLay R Nay
Deal (GA) R Nay
Dent R Nay
Diaz-Balart, L. R Nay
Doolittle R Nay
Drake R Nay
Dreier R Nay
Duncan R Nay
Ehlers R Nay
Emerson R Nay
English (PA) R Nay
Everett R Nay
Feeney R Nay
Ferguson R Nay
Fitzpatrick (PA) R Nay
Flake R Nay
Foley R Nay
Forbes R Nay
Fortenberry R Nay
Fossella R Nay
Foxx R Nay
Franks (AZ) R Nay
Frelinghuysen R Nay
Gallegly R Nay
Garrett (NJ) R Nay
Gerlach R Nay
Gibbons R Nay
Gilchrest R Nay
Gillmor R Nay
Gingrey R Nay
Gohmert R Nay
Goode R Nay
Goodlatte R Nay
Granger R Nay
Graves R Nay
Green (WI) R Nay
Gutknecht R Nay
Hall R Nay
Harris R Nay
Hart R Nay
Hastings (WA) R Nay
Hayes R Nay
Hayworth R Nay
Hefley R Nay
Hensarling R Nay
Herger R Nay
Hobson R Nay
Hoekstra R Nay
Hostettler R Nay
Hulshof R Nay
Hunter R Nay
Inglis (SC) R Nay
Issa R Nay
Istook R Nay
Jenkins R Nay
Jindal R Nay
Johnson (CT) R Nay
Johnson (IL) R Nay
Johnson, Sam R Nay
Jones (NC) R Nay
Keller R Nay
Kelly R Nay
Kennedy (MN) R Nay
King (IA) R Nay
King (NY) R Nay
Kingston R Nay
Kirk R Nay
Kline R Nay
Knollenberg R Nay
Kolbe R Nay
Kuhl (NY) R Nay
LaHood R Nay
LaTourette R Nay
Latham R Nay
Leach R Nay
Lewis (CA) R Nay
Lewis (KY) R Nay
Linder R Nay
LoBiondo R Nay
Lucas R Nay
Lungren, Daniel E. R Nay
Mack R Nay
Manzullo R Nay
Marchant R Nay
McCaul (TX) R Nay
McCotter R Nay
McCrery R Nay
McHenry R Nay
McHugh R Nay
McKeon R Nay
McMorris R Nay
Mica R Nay
Miller (FL) R Nay
Miller (MI) R Nay
Miller, Gary R Nay
Moran (KS) R Nay
Murphy R Nay
Musgrave R Nay
Myrick R Nay
Neugebauer R Nay
Ney R Nay
Northup R Nay
Norwood R Nay
Nunes R Nay
Nussle R Nay
Osborne R Nay
Otter R Nay
Oxley R Nay
Paul R Nay
Pence R Nay
Peterson (PA) R Nay
Petri R Nay
Pitts R Nay
Platts R Nay
Poe R Nay
Pombo R Nay
Porter R Nay
Price (GA) R Nay
Pryce (OH) R Nay
Putnam R Nay
Radanovich R Nay
Ramstad R Nay
Regula R Nay
Rehberg R Nay
Reichert R Nay
Renzi R Nay
Reynolds R Nay
Rogers (AL) R Nay
Rogers (KY) R Nay
Rogers (MI) R Nay
Rohrabacher R Nay
Ros-Lehtinen R Nay
Royce R Nay
Ryan (WI) R Nay
Ryun (KS) R Nay
Saxton R Nay
Schmidt R Nay
Schwarz (MI) R Nay
Sensenbrenner R Nay
Sessions R Nay
Shadegg R Nay
Shaw R Nay
Shays R Nay
Sherwood R Nay
Shimkus R Nay
Shuster R Nay
Simmons R Nay
Simpson R Nay
Smith (NJ) R Nay
Smith (TX) R Nay
Sodrel R Nay
Souder R Nay
Stearns R Nay
Sullivan R Nay
Sweeney R Nay
Tancredo R Nay
Taylor (NC) R Nay
Terry R Nay
Thomas R Nay
Thornberry R Nay
Tiahrt R Nay
Tiberi R Nay
Turner R Nay
Upton R Nay
Walden (OR) R Nay
Walsh R Nay
Wamp R Nay
Weldon (FL) R Nay
Weldon (PA) R Nay
Weller R Nay
Westmoreland R Nay
Whitfield R Nay
Wicker R Nay
Wilson (NM) R Nay
Wilson (SC) R Nay
Wolf R Nay
Young (AK) R Nay
Young (FL) R Nay
Davis (FL) D
Waters D
Diaz-Balart, M. R
Hyde R
Pearce R
Pickering R

Explore This Bill

Investigate this bill → AI summary, roll-call breakdown, and full bill analysis